Awards

Update: Check out the CASTcast pod­cast organ­ized by the Mamo.ca guys! It’s hosted by our friends over at Row Three. Hear me and six other loud­mouths debate the res­ults for an hour! Special thanks to Matt Brown for organ­izing this.

I’m very pleased to announce the res­ults of the 2nd edi­tion of the CAST Awards. I “cast” an even wider net this year, and received 40 com­pleted bal­lots from film lovers in the Greater Toronto Area. Here are the CAST Top 25 voted on from a pre­de­ter­mined list of just over 100 films which had the most pre­lim­inary sup­port. Voters ranked up to 25 films on their ballot from top to bottom, with first choices receiving 25 points, second choices 24, etc. The Points column lists the total score for each film, the Mentions column indic­ates the number of bal­lots it appeared on, and the Seen column indic­ates the total number of voters who have seen the film, even if they didn’t include it on their ballot. I’m proud of the group of critics we’ve gathered, even though I’ve described us else­where as “a ragtag group of semi-professional film blog­gers, tweeters and Lightbox lobby loiterers.” Of the 112 films on the ballot, more than half our voting group saw at least 40, and five saw more than 70!

FILM TITLE
POINTS
MENTIONS
SEEN
1. Drive 548 31 36
2.The Artist 479 26 29
3. The Tree of Life 460 24 27
4. Attack the Block 386 25 36
5. Take Shelter 376 20 21
6. Midnight in Paris 330 24 31
7. Melancholia 306 19 26
8. Shame 284 19 28
9. Beginners 281 19 24
10. Martha Marcy May Marlene 279 20 24
11. Hanna 235 18 28
12. Café de Flore 207 9 13
13.The Raid 205 12 15
14. Blue Valentine 192 11 30
15. Bridesmaids 185 18 31
16.The Muppets 179 14 25
17. The Illusionist 174 11 22
18. The Descendants 172 11 16
19. Super 8 167 16 31
20. Contagion 167 14 22
21. The Interrupters 167 10 12
22. Tabloid 165 12 20
23. Hugo 162 10 23
24. The Trip 159 14 24
25. Meek’s Cutoff 159 10 18

Participants:

Here is a PDF with each person’s ballot and the col­lated res­ults, with a few more inter­esting stats included. Voters could opt out of having their ballot included, so you may notice some omis­sions, but rest assured that each sub­mitted ballot con­trib­uted to the overall results.

And for those still reading, here is my final CAST ballot, ranking 25 films from the list of eli­gible films. In a future blog post, I’ll come up with my own 2011 list(s), sim­ilar to what I did last year and in 2009 and 2008.

My CAST Ballot

  1. The Tree of Life (review)
  2. The Artist (review)
  3. Martha Marcy May Marlene (review)
  4. The Interrupters
  5. Take Shelter
  6. This is Not a Film (review)
  7. The Descendants
  8. Win Win
  9. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
  10. Drive
  11. Attack the Block
  12. Beginners
  13. Hanna
  14. Rango
  15. ALPS (review)
  16. Super 8
  17. Goodbye First Love (review)
  18. The Guard
  19. Contagion
  20. Midnight in Paris
  21. Bridesmaids
  22. Shame (review)
  23. Miss Bala (review)
  24. Cave of Forgotten Dreams
  25. The Ides of March

{ 5 comments }

The Precinct

by James McNally on December 28, 2010

in Awards,Oscars,Screeners

The Precinct

The Precinct (Director: Ilgar Safat): A few weeks ago, I received an email from a Hollywood-based pub­li­cist. I get lots of these sorts of emails, but this one was a bit dif­ferent. How would I like to review Azerbaijan’s sub­mis­sion to the Best Foreign Film cat­egory for this year’s Academy Awards? That’s just the sort of unusual pitch to which I’m likely to respond, so I said sure.

Garib is a pho­to­grapher of erotic nudes working in Baku, the cap­ital of Azerbaijan. His fiancée Sabina is get­ting a bit tired of waiting for Garib to finally settle down and marry her. During an excur­sion to the pic­tur­esque cliffs of Gobustan, he informs her he’ll be leaving again for sev­eral months to work in Africa. They argue during the car ride back and Garib loses con­trol of the car. Fortunately, two police officers come by and pull them from the burning wreck. Instead of of taking them to hos­pital, though, the policemen bring them back to their isol­ated pre­cinct, where their very creepy superior sub­mits Garib to some very probing ques­tions about his past.

Suddenly the film flashes back to Garib’s youth. We learn how he dis­covers a love for pho­to­graphy but also how that interest is used against him by local gang­sters. When a box of old neg­at­ives washes up on shore, some local thugs force Garib to print them at the studio of his beloved pho­to­graphy teacher. When the images turn out to be por­no­graphic, Garib is forced to keep printing them while the thugs sell the prints. After this racket is dis­covered and broken up by the local Communist author­ities, the thugs force Garib to take por­no­graphic photos of Alina, a local girl who’s been turning tricks to sup­port her young brother. Since Garib has been secretly in love with Alina, this drives him to attempt sui­cide. But when he tries to hang him­self, the rope breaks and he’s res­cued by two policemen. Curiously, they are the same two policemen we have seen earlier in the film.

When the film snaps back to the present, Garib seems to under­stand what the pre­cinct is. When the officers throw him into a burning cell, he real­izes he’s in a sort of pur­gatory. Suddenly, he comes to in the burning car with the sound of the approaching police car in his ears.

It’s a fairly ambi­tious struc­ture, although I found the framing story, for all its Kafkaesque atmo­sphere, pretty easy to figure out. The com­bin­a­tion of spiritual/psychological menace is clearly meant to force Garib to con­front some­thing from his past, hence the flash­back. The middle sec­tion of the film is the strongest, keeping to a nat­ur­al­istic tone and shed­ding light on the his­tory of pho­to­graphy and cinema in Azerbaijan. Although the expos­i­tion is some­times a little clumsy, I nev­er­the­less found it quite inter­esting. Visually this sec­tion is strongest as well, for we travel with young Garib all over his child­hood vil­lage and are not con­fined to the dark precinct.

Performances are good, although there’s not really much in terms of char­acter devel­op­ment. Garib learns his lesson but it’s only clear from the flash­back and flash­for­ward. Within the pre­cinct, the per­form­ances are pitched a little high, to match the eeri­ness of the situ­ation. Overall, the film was enter­taining without being excep­tional. This is the first Azeri film I’ve ever seen, and I was impressed with the pro­duc­tion values for the most part. But I think would have been hap­pier to see a film based entirely on Garib’s child­hood rather than trying to graft that coming-of-age story onto a more genre-based psychological/horror story.

6/10(6/10)

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

I’m very pleased to announce the res­ults of the inaug­ural CAST Awards. If you’ll pardon the pun, I “cast” a fairly wide net among my cinephile friends and am pleased with the level of par­ti­cip­a­tion. I received 31 com­pleted bal­lots from film lovers in the Greater Toronto Area. Here are the CAST Top 25 voted on from a pre­de­ter­mined list of just over 100 films which had the most pre­lim­inary sup­port. Voters ranked up to 25 films on their ballot from top to bottom, with first choices receiving 25 points, second choices 24, etc. The Points column lists the total score for each film, and the Mentions column indic­ates the number of bal­lots it appeared on.

FILM TITLE
POINTS
MENTIONS
1. Inception 411 22
2. Toy Story 3 311 20
3. Black Swan 307 16
4. Shutter Island 297 19
5. The Social Network 261 17
6. Scott Pilgrim 254 17
7. The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 231 16
8. Winter’s Bone 180 11
9. I Am Love 165 9
10.The King’s Speech 149 11
11. Rubber 149 9
12. Never Let Me Go 147 11
13. Trigger 140 9
14. Fish Tank 134 9
15. Buried 134 9
16. The White Ribbon 130 7
17. True Grit 127 9
18. Chloe 124 8
19. Easy A 121 10
20. Marwencol 117 7
21. 127 Hours 115 9
22. A Prophet 114 8
23. Rabbit Hole 112 7
24. Blue Valentine 110 8
25. Heartbeats 110 7

Participants:

Here is a PDF with each person’s ballot and the col­lated res­ults, with a few more inter­esting stats included.

And for those still reading, here is my final CAST ballot, ranking 25 films from the list of eli­gible films. In a future blog post, I’ll come up with my own 2010 list(s), sim­ilar to what I did last year.

My CAST Ballot

  1. NY Export: Opus Jazz (review)
  2. Incendies
  3. Marwencol (review)
  4. Never Let Me Go
  5. Black Swan
  6. Balada Triste (review)
  7. Carlos (review)
  8. Rubber
  9. Trigger
  10. Blue Valentine
  11. Inception
  12. Waste Land (review)
  13. Toy Story 3
  14. Submarine (review)
  15. The Social Network
  16. Exit Through The Gift Shop
  17. Shutter Island
  18. Meek’s Cutoff
  19. Fish Tank
  20. Inside Job (review)
  21. The King’s Speech
  22. Greenberg (review)
  23. True Grit
  24. Poetry
  25. The Misfortunates

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

CAST Awards

A few years back, I began meeting up with a couple of local film blog­gers for monthly drinks. We talked about the films we were seeing and at the end of the year, we’d debate our year-end lists, com­paring them with the list of the Toronto Film Critics Association, among other critics’ groups. Wouldn’t it be great if our little group could come up with our own list, I thought. But there were just a few of us, and we couldn’t pos­sibly see as many films as the “pros.”

Fast for­ward just a few years, and our little group has grown to more than two dozen. And although none of us yet earn our daily bread from film writing, most of us have access to many more films due to fest­ival accred­it­a­tions and DVD screeners. So I thought it was time we came up with a list of our own.

Though our group doesn’t have a name, we invented one for the pur­pose of the awards. Say hello to the Cinema Appreciation Society of Toronto. No, there are no mem­ber­ship require­ments or secret hand­shakes. It encom­passes everyone in my email address book who sees a lot of films and who lives in Toronto or reas­on­ably close by. We didn’t pick the name for its ref­er­ence to broken bones (as in the above photo), but more for its asso­ci­ation with the cast of a film, or with the act of “casting” a vote.

To keep things simple the first year, there is only one cat­egory on the offi­cial ballot. I asked approx­im­ately 40 people to list up to 25 films they saw this year in order of pref­er­ence. These pre­lim­inary bal­lots were tab­u­lated and then the top 100 vote-getting films were added to a final ballot. These bal­lots went out on December 3rd to the same group, who were asked to come up with another Top 25 based on this final ballot. In addi­tion, any film released the­at­ric­ally in Toronto during the month of December was eligible.

The dead­line to receive com­pleted bal­lots is mid­night tonight, and I’ve already been busy tab­u­lating res­ults. Look for the inaug­ural CAST Top 25 some­time tomorrow!

Special thanks to Johan Karlborg, for making the photo of his cast avail­able under a Creative Commons licence. I hope your wrist has finally healed!

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Last night, Hot Docs presented their awards for the 2009 fest­ival. Congratulations to all the winnners:

Best Canadian Feature Documentary
INVISIBLE CITY
Director: Hubert Davis
Producers: Mehernaz Lentin, Gerry Flahive
Executive Producer: Silva Basmajian (NFB)
Sponsored by the Documentary Organization of Canada and the Brian Linehan Charitable Foundation
$15,000 prize cour­tesy of the Brian Linehan Charitable Foundation

Special Jury Prize — Canadian Feature
WATERLIFE
Director: Kevin McMahon
Producers: Michael McMahon, Kristina McLaughlin, Gerry Flahive
Executive Producers: Mark Achbar, Betsy Carson, Michael McMahon, Silva Basmajian (NFB)
Sponsored by the Brian Linehan Charitable Foundation
$10,000 prize cour­tesy of the Brian Linehan Charitable Foundation

Best International Feature Documentary
THE ONE MAN VILLAGE
Director/Producer: Simon El Habre
Producers: Jad Abi-Khalil, Irit Neidhardt
Sponsored by A&E
$10,000 prize cour­tesy of Hot Docs

Special Jury Prize — International Feature
COOKING HISTORY
Director/Producer: Peter Kerekes
Producers: Georg Misch, Pavel Strnad
Executive Producer: Ralph Wieser
Sponsored by the OMDC

Best Mid-Length Documentary
RABBIT À LA BERLIN
Director: Bartek Konopka
Producer: Anna Wydra
Sponsored by Canada Council for the Arts

Best Short Documentary
THE DELIAN MODE
Director/Producer: Kara Blake
Producer: Marie-Josée Saint-Pierre
Sponsored by Playback

doc­u­mentary’s Don Haig Award
Brett Gaylor
Tracey Deer
Awarded by the Don Haig Award Committee — $20,000 cash prize gen­er­ously sponsored by doc­u­mentary

The Lindalee Tracey Award
Laura Bari
Will Inrig
$6,000 cash prize and film stock donated by Kodak Canada and valued at $3,000

HBO Documentary Films Emerging Artist Award
Chung-ryoul Lee
OLD PARTNER
Sponsored by HBO Documentary Films

Hot Docs Outstanding Achievement Award
Presented to Alanis Obomsawin by the Hot Docs Board of Directors

{ Comments on this entry are closed }