From the daily archives:

Monday, September 11, 2006

Offside

by James McNally on September 11, 2006

in Film Festivals,TIFF

Offside

Offside (Iran, dir­ector Jafar Panahi): Filmed during an actual qual­i­fying match for the 2006 World Cup, Offside works bril­liantly as both a comedy and a tragedy. The film fol­lows the for­tunes of a group of young women who are caught trying to sneak into a foot­ball match at Tehran’s Azadi Stadium. The country’s Islamic reli­gious leaders have decreed that women may not sit with men at sporting events, lest they be exposed to cursing and other mor­ally ques­tion­able beha­viour. This hasn’t stopped the country’s young female fans, who con­tinue to sneak in using various tricks. But Panahi focuses on a small group who have been caught and are being detained agon­iz­ingly close to the action. They beg the bored sol­diers guarding them to let them go or at least to let them watch the match. The sol­diers tell them they shouldn’t have tried to get in, that they could have watched the game at home on TV. They banter back and forth in almost real-time as the game con­tinues, just off-camera.

There is one very funny sequence where a young sol­dier accom­panies one of the girls to the restroom. Since there are no female restrooms at sta­diums, he has to clear the room of any men before he can allow her to go in. Plus, he makes her cover her face so no one can see she’s a woman. This is accom­plished using a poster of Iranian soccer star Ali Karimi as a mask, with eye holes punched out.

You get a real sense that even the sol­diers are baffled by the pro­hib­i­tion, and are only car­rying out their orders so as to hasten the end of their com­pulsory mil­itary ser­vice. One sol­dier com­plains that he was sup­posed to be on leave so he could take care of his family’s cattle in the coun­tryside. Little by little, the girls and the sol­diers talk to each other, and there are numerous small acts of kind­ness on both sides to show that these are basic­ally good people living in ter­rible cir­cum­stances. However, the sol­diers’ con­stant reminder that “the chief” is on his way lends a sense of menace, since we don’t know what sort of pun­ish­ment the women will face.

Unlike most Iranian films, which are known for their strong visuals, Offside is filmed in a realist style with no arti­fice. In fact, the film was made during the actual qual­i­fying match against Bahrain that took place on June 5, 2005. The “plot” in many ways was determ­ined by the result on the pitch. If Iran won the match, they would qualify. If they lost, they would not. Since the World Cup has come and gone, I don’t think it is a spoiler to say that Iran won the match. The scenes of cel­eb­ra­tion at the end of the film were real and spon­tan­eous, which gave the film a real authen­ti­city. Seeing how much this meant to the people of Iran was deeply touching.

As well, one of the young women makes ref­er­ence at the end of the film to seven fans who died during the Iran-Japan match on March 25, just a few weeks before. They were trampled to death after police began to spray the crowd with water to move them in a cer­tain dir­ec­tion. Knowing that this was a real-life tragedy added another level of poignancy to the celebrations.

I don’t want to go off on a long polit­ical tan­gent, but this film gave me real hope that there are those in Iran who are hoping for change and working at it. Iran is a nation of young people, and it is only a matter of time before they take the place of their elders in the polit­ical sphere. Films like this one show the proud spirit of the Iranian people in spite of their present dif­fi­culties, and it’s my sin­cere hope that there is a brighter future for them.

Interview with dir­ector Jafar Panahi

Interview with dir­ector Jafar Panahi at Reverse Shot

Good review from Sight and Sound magazine

9/10(9/10)

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

The Host

by James McNally on September 11, 2006

in Film Festivals,TIFF

The Host

The Host (Korea, dir­ector Bong Joon-ho): A huge box office hit in Korea, The Host is a good old-fashioned mon­ster movie, and a lot more. The dir­ector intro­duced the screening by saying that the film isn’t really a mon­ster movie at all, but an emo­tional Korean family drama, and he’s right, mostly.

The family in ques­tion is a strange one. There are no mothers and no spouses, just a grand­father, his three unmar­ried chil­dren, and the daughter of his eldest son, whose mother aban­doned her shortly after she was born. The grand­father and eldest son run a food stand next to the Han River, and one day, a gigantic lizard-like mon­ster emerges from the water and attacks the people pic­nicking along the riverb­anks. In the pro­cess, 13-year-old Hyun-seo is car­ried off before the hor­ri­fied eyes of her father Kang-du. The family grieves together in the hos­pital to where they’ve all been quar­ant­ined until Kang-du receives a staticky cell-phone call from his daughter, who is alive and beg­ging him to come and rescue her from the monster’s lair, some­where in the sewer system.

The reason for the quar­antine is that the gov­ern­ment believes the mon­ster is car­rying some sort of virus and are trying to limit exposure to the rest of the city. The problem is that they’ve called back all the troops that they’d first sent to cap­ture the mon­ster, and now it falls to this dys­func­tional family to find their child. After breaking out of the hos­pital, the whole group embarks on a search and rescue mis­sion armed only with a couple of rifles and sister Nam-ju’s bow (she’s a bronze medal-winning archer). They’re all inef­fec­tual in unique ways. While Nam-ju (Bae Doo-Na, so great in last year’s Linda Linda Linda) is an excel­lent archer, she’s slow to take aim, which cost her the gold medal. Brother Nam-il is a uni­ver­sity graduate who can’t find work, so he’s turned to booze. And Kang-du is just gen­er­ally lazy and a bit dim-witted.

There is quite a bit of humour in the way the family mem­bers interact, as well as a fair bit of social and polit­ical satire at the expense of both the Korean and U.S. gov­ern­ments (the Americans are blamed for dumping toxic waste that cre­ated the mon­ster in the first place). This was amusing, though pretty heavy-handed.

The cine­ma­to­graphy made use of lots of rain and cloudy skies to convey the claus­tro­phobic feeling of the sewers even when we weren’t actu­ally there. In fact, the only sunny skies in the film occur just before the monster’s first appearance.

While I did find the film enjoy­able, I felt it ran a bit long, and stretched cred­ib­ility a few times too many. It’s a mon­ster movie, after all, so maybe I shouldn’t have had such high expect­a­tions. The effects are well-done and it was cer­tainly fun to watch, but it’s not an art film by any stretch of the ima­gin­a­tion. The theme seemed to be that even dys­func­tional fam­ilies are still fam­ilies, and that we need to take care of each other and not expect our gov­ern­ments to pro­tect or rescue us.

7/10(7/10)

{ Comments on this entry are closed }