My 2009 List of Lists

by James McNally on January 3, 2010 · 2 comments

in Lists

I’ve been avoiding making any year-end “Best of 2009″ list and have been waiting for the flood of other people’s lists to pass me by, but now, goaded by TSS co-founder and now-just-occasional con­trib­utor Jay Kerr, I’ve decided to draw atten­tion to some of the best films I saw in 2009 in my own unique way. No simple Top Ten for me. No way. I’m far too afraid of get­ting the order wrong, and besides, I’m not a pro­fes­sional film critic. I don’t see most of the major releases. In fact, if I don’t want to see a cer­tain film, I don’t see it. And if I see it and don’t feel like reviewing it, I don’t review it. So I’m not really qual­i­fied to come up with a com­pre­hensive list. Instead, enjoy a whole bunch of non-ranked lists from my filmgoing exper­i­ences of 2009. Films marked with an * actu­ally appeared on my 2008 list as well.

P.S. I also get con­fused as to which films are actu­ally eli­gible for these lists. Some films I saw in 2009 haven’t been released the­at­ric­ally yet, while others that were released the­at­ric­ally I actu­ally saw in 2008 or before. And some­times things that come out in the US have dif­ferent release dates in Canada, or vice versa. It makes my head hurt.

Favourite Documentary Films of 2009

Favourites from TIFF 2009

Favourite Non-Festival Films from 2009

Favourite Films from 2008 That Are Appearing on a Lot of 2009 Lists

Favourite Undistributed Films of 2009 (no known dis­tri­bu­tion in US or Canada)

Perhaps this next list is most important, because it tells you that I’m far from qual­i­fied to judge 2009’s best films when I haven’t seen many which are being con­sidered for awards and are on other critics’ lists.

Biggest Omissions in My Filmgoing in 2009

{ 2 comments }

1 Bob Turnbull January 4, 2010 at 10:04 am

Hey James! Happy New Year sir!

Good lists…Yeah, I’m similar to you in my approach – I have no intention of seeing everything that is awards worthy. There’s just too much good stuff from past years I’ve missed and other hidden gems that I try to only see films that I expect I will enjoy (I’m nowhere near 100% accurate on that front by any means) or that I think will challenge me in some way. Otherwise, it just feels like homework and I don’t want that.

I’ve seen 4 of your list of “haven’t seen yet” – “Inglourious Basterds” is great fun if you can get past the icky-ness that is Eli Roth. “Up In The Air” is 3/4 excellent and final quarter disappointing, but still worth it. “The Informant!” was a disappointment at TIFF, but I feel like I missed some of the rhythms of the film and would like to see it again (though that may just be the Soderbergh apologist in me…B-) ). “Public Enemies” was somewhat inert.

Mr. Fox is one of my faves of the year (my own year lists should be going up today or tomorrow – I put up my decade ones up over the weekend). And I was surprised by how much I really liked (and seem to be growing fonder of as time passes) 500 Days Of Summer. I expected something too self-consciously quirky, but got something very different. I just saw “Lorna’s Silence” over the holidays (nothing says Christmas like illegal Albanian refugees, eh?) and I thought it was pretty terrific. I liked it a greal deal more than The Dardennes’ more well known “L’Enfant”.

And you just reminded me of how much I enjoyed “Big River Man”. Insanity captured on film.

As for categorizing things by years, I have avoided any attempts to be accurate – so I just use IMDB as my guide. I have one single place to look and I stay away from the vagueries of release schedules. Of course, then I miss the chance to plug a film from 2007 that gets released in 2009, but so be it.

Hope to catch up with you soon…

2 Jay Kerr January 7, 2010 at 10:56 pm

Finally! Thanks for posting this. I’m always looking for recommendations and yours are some of the best!

I wasn’t sure if you liked Bad Lieutenant or not. Crazy movie.

I really have to see Food Inc. A lot of people have been raving about it. I should have seen Fantastic Mr. Fox instead of Up In The Air for a second time (this time with Lissa). Daniel saw FMF and loved it.

Thanks for the list. I may have to borrow a few screeners.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: