From the daily archives:

Wednesday, September 15, 2004

Bad Education

by James McNally on September 15, 2004

in Film Festivals,TIFF

Bad Education (La Mala Educación) (Spain, dir­ector Pedro Almodóvar): I’m really having trouble coming up with things to say about this film. I’m new to Almodóvar films (Talk to Her was the first one I saw), and maybe I just don’t “get” him yet, but I must say I left this film with a vague feeling of dis­ap­point­ment. Outlining the plot is dif­fi­cult, but it begins as a story of two child­hood friends reunited in adult­hood. One is a film dir­ector and the other a strug­gling actor who shows him a short story that he’d like to see developed into a film. It is a par­tially auto­bi­o­graph­ical account of the sexual abuse exper­i­enced at the strict Catholic school where both boys met. The two boys also fall in love there, and the jeal­ousy of a priest con­spires to sep­arate them forever. To be honest, this sec­tion of the film was the most enjoy­able for me. Despite the horror of abuse, it’s very dis­creetly implied, and the inno­cence of child­hood love is refreshing. Unfortunately, this sec­tion, seem­ingly so important, only lasts about ten or fif­teen minutes. The rest is a tangled telling and retelling of events that came later, when sex becomes a com­modity for everyone involved. The plot is com­plic­ated by the fact that each char­acter is being played by two or three dif­ferent actors, and des­pite having only a handful of char­ac­ters (all male, by the way), the film never really lets us get to know them or their motivations.

Despite that, it’s a clev­erly con­structed film, and shot beau­ti­fully. It’s hard to think that even a dis­ap­pointing Almodóvar film can be better than most Hollywood product, but alas, it’s true.

Film’s Web Site: www.lamalaeducacion.com

Director’s Web Site: www.pedroalmodovar.es

8/10(8/10)

{ Comments on this entry are closed }